Samuel Johnson's Valuation of Comedy Over Tragedy in the ‘Preface to Shakespeare’
Samuel Johnson, an influential literary critic, lexicographer, and writer of the 18th century, provides a profound analysis of William Shakespeare's works in his “Preface to Shakespeare” (1765). In this critical essay, Johnson evaluates Shakespeare's contributions to both comedy and tragedy, offering insights into the playwright's strengths and the enduring appeal of his works. One of Johnson's notable arguments is his preference for comedy over tragedy. This essay explores the reasons behind Johnson's valuation of comedy, examining his critical perspectives on realism, moral instruction, universality, and the human experience. It also considers the broader context of 18th-century literary criticism and Johnson's own literary sensibilities.
1. Realism and Representation of Life
One of Johnson's primary reasons for valuing comedy over tragedy is its superior representation of real life. Johnson believed that comedy, by its very nature, offers a more accurate and relatable depiction of human behavior and social interactions.
Realistic Portrayal of Characters
Johnson argues that comedy excels in portraying characters who are more reflective of everyday people. While tragedy often involves noble characters and grandiose themes, comedy focuses on ordinary individuals and their follies, eccentricities, and idiosyncrasies. This focus allows audiences to see themselves in the characters, fostering a sense of connection and identification.
Tragic Heroes vs. Comic Characters: Tragic heroes are typically extraordinary individuals facing exceptional circumstances, which can sometimes create a sense of distance from the audience. In contrast, comic characters are usually more relatable, presenting familiar flaws and humorous situations that resonate with common experiences.
Everyday Life: Comedy often draws from the mundane aspects of life, depicting social interactions, misunderstandings, and common conflicts. This realism makes comedy a more effective medium for reflecting the human condition in its everyday context.
Social Satire and Critique
Johnson also appreciates the role of comedy in social satire and critique. Through humor, comedy can expose societal vices, hypocrisies, and absurdities in a manner that is both entertaining and thought-provoking.
Satirical Edge: Comedy's ability to use satire to critique social norms and behaviors provides a platform for reflecting on and questioning societal values. This aspect of comedy allows it to serve as a mirror to society, highlighting its flaws and encouraging reform.
Humor and Reflection: The humorous nature of comedy makes its critiques more palatable and accessible. Audiences are more likely to engage with and reflect on the societal issues presented through comedy, as the use of humor softens the impact of criticism.
2. Moral Instruction and Ethical Lessons
Johnson values comedy for its potential to impart moral instruction and ethical lessons. He believes that comedy's focus on human follies and vices provides a platform for teaching important moral lessons in a way that is engaging and memorable.
Highlighting Human Follies
Comedy often highlights human weaknesses, such as vanity, greed, and foolishness, through exaggeration and humor. By exposing these flaws in a light-hearted manner, comedy encourages audiences to recognize and correct their own behaviors.
Moral Improvement: Johnson argues that by presenting characters who are clearly flawed and subject to ridicule, comedy can promote self-awareness and moral improvement. The laughter elicited by comedy can lead to introspection and a desire to avoid similar follies.
Positive Reinforcement: Comedy often ends on a positive note, with characters experiencing growth or receiving their comeuppance. This resolution reinforces moral lessons, emphasizing the benefits of virtuous behavior and the consequences of vice.
Ethical Reflection
Comedy's emphasis on everyday situations and relatable characters also makes it an effective vehicle for ethical reflection. Audiences can see the moral implications of characters' actions and decisions, providing a framework for considering their own ethical choices.
Relatability and Empathy: The relatable nature of comic characters fosters empathy, allowing audiences to understand and reflect on the ethical dimensions of their actions. This empathy enhances the moral impact of comedy, encouraging audiences to consider their own behavior in a similar light.
Accessible Morality: The accessible and entertaining nature of comedy makes its moral lessons more impactful. Audiences are more likely to absorb and remember ethical lessons presented in a humorous context, making comedy an effective tool for moral instruction.
3. Universality and Enduring Appeal
Johnson values comedy for its universality and enduring appeal. He argues that comedy's focus on human nature and social interactions transcends cultural and temporal boundaries, making it a timeless and universally relevant form of literature.
Timeless Themes
Comedy often deals with themes that are universal and enduring, such as love, friendship, and social dynamics. These themes resonate with audiences across different cultures and historical periods, contributing to the lasting appeal of comic works.
Human Nature: Comedy's exploration of human nature, with its inherent flaws and virtues, makes it relevant to audiences regardless of their cultural background. The fundamental aspects of human behavior depicted in comedy are recognizable and relatable across time and place.
Social Dynamics: The social interactions and relationships depicted in comedy reflect common experiences and concerns, ensuring its continued relevance. The humor and satire in comedy address issues that are perpetually present in human societies, such as power dynamics, social norms, and interpersonal conflicts.
Enduring Popularity
Johnson acknowledges that comedy's ability to entertain and amuse contributes to its enduring popularity. The enjoyment derived from humor and laughter ensures that comic works remain appealing to audiences over time.
Entertainment Value: The primary purpose of comedy is to entertain, and its ability to elicit laughter and enjoyment ensures its lasting appeal. The entertainment value of comedy makes it a popular choice among audiences, ensuring its continued relevance and popularity.
Adaptability: Comedy's flexible and adaptable nature allows it to evolve with changing social norms and cultural contexts. This adaptability ensures that comic works can be continually reinterpreted and appreciated by new generations of audiences.
4. Johnson’s Critical Perspectives
Johnson's preference for comedy over tragedy is also influenced by his broader critical perspectives and literary sensibilities. His appreciation for realism, moral instruction, and universality aligns with his valuation of comedy as a superior literary form.
Realism and Relatability
Johnson's critical emphasis on realism and relatability aligns with his preference for comedy. He values literature that accurately reflects human experiences and social interactions, and he believes that comedy achieves this more effectively than tragedy.
Accurate Representation: Johnson's appreciation for the accurate representation of life and human behavior in comedy reflects his belief in the importance of realism in literature. He values works that provide a truthful and relatable depiction of the human condition.
Connection with Audiences: Johnson's preference for literature that fosters a connection with audiences aligns with his valuation of comedy. He believes that the relatable nature of comic characters and situations enhances the audience's engagement and appreciation.
Moral and Ethical Dimensions
Johnson's belief in the moral and ethical dimensions of literature informs his preference for comedy. He values works that provide moral instruction and ethical reflection, and he believes that comedy achieves this more effectively than tragedy.
Moral Instruction: Johnson's emphasis on the moral instruction provided by comedy reflects his belief in the didactic purpose of literature. He values works that promote virtuous behavior and ethical reflection, and he believes that comedy achieves this in an engaging and memorable way.
Ethical Reflection: Johnson's appreciation for the ethical reflection fostered by comedy aligns with his broader critical perspectives. He values literature that encourages audiences to consider their own ethical choices and behaviors, and he believes that comedy provides an effective framework for this reflection.
5. Broader Context of 18th-Century Literary Criticism
Johnson's valuation of comedy over tragedy must also be understood within the broader context of 18th-century literary criticism. During this period, there was a growing emphasis on realism, moral instruction, and the accessibility of literature, which influenced Johnson's critical perspectives.
Realism and Moral Instruction
The 18th century saw a growing emphasis on realism and moral instruction in literature. Critics and writers valued works that provided an accurate depiction of life and promoted virtuous behavior, reflecting broader Enlightenment values.
Enlightenment Values: The Enlightenment emphasis on reason, rationality, and moral improvement influenced literary criticism during the 18th century. Critics valued works that reflected these values, contributing to the preference for realism and moral instruction in literature.
Realistic Representation: The growing emphasis on realistic representation in literature influenced the critical evaluation of different literary forms. Comedy's focus on everyday life and relatable characters aligned with this emphasis, contributing to its favorable evaluation.
Accessibility and Popularity
The 18th century also saw a growing emphasis on the accessibility and popularity of literature. Critics and writers valued works that could reach and engage a broad audience, reflecting a democratization of literary culture.
Democratization of Literature: The growing emphasis on accessibility and popularity in literature reflected broader social and cultural changes during the 18th century. Critics valued works that could reach a broad audience, contributing to the preference for comedy, which was seen as more accessible and engaging.
Enduring Appeal: The emphasis on the enduring appeal of literature influenced the critical evaluation of different literary forms. Comedy's ability to entertain and engage audiences over time contributed to its favorable evaluation by critics like Johnson.
Conclusion
Samuel Johnson's preference for comedy over tragedy in his "Preface to Shakespeare" is rooted in his deep-seated appreciation for realism, moral instruction, universality, and the enduring appeal of literature. Through his critical evaluation, Johnson asserts that comedy excels in portraying the complexities of human nature with authenticity and relatability. Unlike tragedy, which often focuses on exceptional individuals in extraordinary circumstances, comedy delves into the everyday follies and intricacies of ordinary life. This focus allows comedy to resonate more profoundly with audiences across different cultures and time periods, fostering a deeper connection and understanding of the human experience.
Moreover, Johnson values comedy for its ability to serve as a vehicle for moral instruction and ethical reflection. By exposing human flaws and societal absurdities through humor and satire, comedy prompts audiences to contemplate their own behaviors and values. Johnson believes that the accessible nature of comedy makes it an effective medium for conveying moral lessons, as the laughter it evokes facilitates a more profound engagement with ethical dilemmas and social critiques.
In the broader context of 18th-century literary criticism, Johnson's preference for comedy reflects the era's emphasis on realism, moral improvement, and the democratization of literature. As Enlightenment values of reason and rationality permeated intellectual discourse, critics like Johnson sought literature that could entertain, educate, and morally uplift readers from all walks of life. Comedy's ability to entertain while simultaneously addressing profound social and ethical issues aligned with these ideals, making it a favored genre among critics and audiences alike.
Ultimately, Samuel Johnson's valuation of comedy over tragedy in his "Preface to Shakespeare" underscores the enduring relevance and universal appeal of comedic literature. By celebrating the wit, insight, and moral depth inherent in Shakespearean comedy, Johnson invites readers to appreciate the genre's unique ability to illuminate the human condition with both humor and wisdom.
Comments
Post a Comment